Before anyone complains about this looong recap and me fawning over Patrick, bitching about how ugly Robin's shirts are, and drooling over Becky Herbst's bone structure, please remember that a slight majority of you sort-of asked for this.
Thank you.
We open with Patrick hotly arriving home from the hospital to Robin, who seems gloomy, prompting Patrick to hotly question "Baby, what's wrong?" She's just new-mom exhausted, having not had time to clean the house or change her clothes or remove the eau de baby spit-up that Emma gave her. They adorably cuddle on the couch while Patrick hotly tells her he had a day from hell, including a 10-hour surgery on a little boy. Robin has had a busy day and rattles off a litany of things, including Mac calling about having bought a huge turkey (aw!). Robin asks what Patrick would have been doing over the holidays in his bachelor days, and while he says he'd have been someplace tropical, Robin points out that she met him in December and he was very much not in the tropics, in fact she walked in on him in the hospital shagging a nurse. He says she should have knocked. Ha.
Patrick looks like he is going to fall asleep sitting up while Robin gets all deep:
Robin: You know, sometimes it's crazy to think that just one decision can change your entire life. Like if you turn left then one thing will happen ... I don't know, there's ... I know there's a name for it, I just can't think of it right now.
Patrick: It's the Butterfly Effect.
Robin: I'm in love with a really smart man.
Patrick: Yes, you am. They say when a ... lay down [Robin cutely puts her head on a pillow in his lap] ... they say when a butterfly flaps its wings in China, it changes the weather in New York. Some people call it fate; that destiny is inevitable. And if you're meant to love someone, you will love them, no matter when or how you met.
As Robin dozes off, we get the classic tingly sounds and fuzzy screen that let you know we're in a soapy dream/alternate reality.
Epiphany, Kelly, and Lainey greet Robin, who has just arrived from a visit to Paris yet inexplicably is wearing a hideously ugly top. Robin is laden with gifts for her roomies, Lainey and Kelly, and for Epiphany. I should focus on something else, like how different must Epiphany be in an alternate reality to deserve a gift from Paris, but I am fixated on this shirt. Oh, Alternate Reality Robin, you disappoint me.


This thing is equal parts maddening and confusing. It's like Gunne Sax tried to make club wear.
Robin wants to know what's new, and what's new is a neurosurgeon named Patrick Drake. He is "smokin' hot" according to Kelly, and we know she is correct because 1) even a broken clock is right twice a day, and 2) her variable group by which to measure hotness is enormous. Lainey and Epiphany fill in that he's also an arrogant horndog, but Kelly is stuck on the hot part. As she always . . . No, you know what? I'm not going to make the easy slut joke there. I'm taking a stand!
Robin checks herself out in the locker room mirror and somehow manages not to rip that hideola top right off her tiny frame. Perhaps given another minute she would have, but she's distracted by giggling coming from the shower.

Of course, Patrick is in there with a nurse. Leyla, to be precise. Kimberly McCullough demonstrates reason #178 she is awesome with this Expression Hall of Fame-worthy "Leyla?!"

A shirtless and kind of douchebaggy Patrick is all "we're a little busy in here." Let's focus less on the douchebaggy, more on the shirtless, shall we? And the hotness.
The regular credits play, to remind you of the shitfest you have to suffer through every other day of the year to get this one holiday-themed mob-free nugget of soapiness.