• About Us
  • FAQ
  • Archives
  • Links
  • SOD Columns


  • Serial Drama on Facebook

Subscribe to Serial Drama

  • Add to Google Reader or Homepage

    Subscribe in Bloglines

    Add to My AOL

    Powered by FeedBurner

« The One With Brand New Information | Main | Much Like Ricky Martin, I Must Share My Truth »

March 30, 2010

Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered

I spent much of today's All My Children completely disoriented: what the hell time was it in Pine Valley with all of these things going on? Was it the middle of the night? Was it the crack of dawn? And if so, why was half the town all gussied up and functioning, and why was the other half strolling around the Chandler mansion in bathrobes?! SO CONFUSED. Not helping my confusion was the fact that, when the episode began, I had just woken up from an impromptu nap myself and had no idea what day it was (cue Andy Dwyer's "I'm suuuper bad at days") (If you are not watching Parks and Recreation, you should be! Don't let the lackluster first season scare you away from what is one of the best sitcoms on TV!) (Do you think there is any way that I could classify the NBC Thursday night lineup and How I Met Your Mother as soaps so that I can discus them here?) (How many parenthetical notations are too many for a tiny sentence?).

But once I realized that it was Tuesday and could think clearly again, I found myself watching an episode of All My Childrenthat wasn't wholly bad and, indeed, contained some moments that were genuinely good and seriously entertaining, alongside the bizarre and irritating moments that have become synonymous with present-day AMC.


Let's start with the good, and I think we all know where I am going to go with this one, because I have been super vocal in my fondness for this pairing and am toeing the crazy line: David + Greenlee + Declaration of love = !!!!!!<33333!!!!!

It's funny--not "ha ha" funny, but "Oh my effing goodness, Charles Pratt seriously set fire to everything good and enjoyable about AMC" funny--that, not too long ago, I was actively hoping for David Hayward's death. I hoped for Adam to be the one to do him in, maybe with his bare hands, and possibly displaying his body on the walls of the mansion as a warning for anyone willing to tangle with a Chandler. I hated him, is what I'm saying. These writers, though, have done a spectacular job* of going back to basics and rediscovering what used to be so great about David and have made him not merely tolerable, but enjoyable, to the point where I am rooting for this romance, hard, even though I know it will only end with my tears.

*This is not to say that this writing staff is perfect, because, seriously, the average episode of this show is so soul-crushingly boring that I am horrified to even contemplate what it is like to spend time with the writers in a social situation. I feel like they are the type of people who spend a lot of time at parties talking about how moist the cake is.

Even though I will inevitably be disappointed, do you blame me for getting swept up in this? Vincent Irizarry and Rebecca Budig are SO GOOD together. I keep saying that, I know, but it's true. The way he ruefully smiled at Greens (who looked prettier than ever and was wearing a seriously killer coat) and pledged his love to her? So good.

David: This is something you can trust: I'm a heartless bastard. I am cold, I am cruel.
Greenlee: Not to me.
David: Any woman that I've ever felt anything for, I don't only just hurt them, I decimate their loves. And I'm not going to do that to you?
Greenlee: What, exactly, do you feel for me?
David: Greenlee, please stop pushing.
Greenlee: Say it! Are we friends? Are we more, are we less? Do you love me like a sister, like a distant cousin?
David: All right, damn it. Yes. Yes! I love you, okay? I love you so much it's scaring the hell out of me, and that's why it has to end, right now. Because if it doesn't, god help us both. That's your cue to turn and run for the hills.
Greenlee: I'm not going anywhere.
David: Whatever you feel for me, Greenlee, gratitude, affection...it doesn't come close to how I feel for you, and that kind of love, it crushes people that I don't intend to hurt. I'm not going to do this, Greenlee. I swore to protect you and am going to keep this promise, okay? Even if it means to protect you from me. So please, help me do that.
Greenlee: You've been nothing but kind and gentle to me.
David: Damn it, Greenlee. I need you to do this. All right? Whatever you feel for me, or think that you feel for me, you have to promise me not to say you love me again, unless you mean it. If that day ever comes, I give you my promise that i will fight to be the man who deserves you love, until the day I die.

I mean, really, people, I'm not made of stone! This show has deprived me of a good, old-fashioned soap romance for so long. Like, what, am I supposed to be swept away by the great love of JR and Marissa?!


Also firmly in the "good" category was Erica and Brooke, doing what they do best: exchanging barbs while treating each other with a cold civility. Seriously, the peals of fake laughter while glaring at one another warmed my heart, which says a whole lot about my heart...

Erica: You know, Brooke, just because you spent your life competing with me doesn't mean that every other woman turns everything into a competition.

Erica: How's your love life?
Brooke: I'm not even on my second cup of coffee.
Erica: Oh! I'm sorry, I'm sorry. I didn't realize it was such a touchy subject.

Erica: Well, I mean, you must be lonely from time to time. I know it can be sometimes difficult for...certain women to meet a good man.

Raise your hand if you'd watch an entire show of these two sniping at each other? What network can we pitch this to? Obviously not SOAPNet, since it involves a soap and has the potential to be awesome, which is in direct opposition to their mission to broadcast old box office failures.


I'm not sure if the writers are actually going to go there with Annie and JR, or if Jacob Young's face is lighting up in their scenes because he's excited to be working with someone who actually emotes, but...well, when Annie said, "You know I had divorce papers drawn up and you're trying to nail me with them", he smiled the most lascivious smile. I was actually taken aback!

JR then had a conversation about, um, something, with Marissa, and I completely forgot that she even appeared on-screen until I re-watched the episode (to get a particular quote, not because I enjoyed it THAT much). She is just completely devoid of personality and charisma.


Colby and Damon had a nice bonding sesh, and I have to admit that Natalie Hall has completely grown on me. She's either toned down her over-enunciation or the writing for her has improved so that I don't notice it as much, and she's so, so very pretty.

Their conversation being as stereotypically teen as it was is either a realistic move on the part of the writers (because, seriously, I know that I had that kind of impassioned conversation many times throughout high school) or just another example of the writers fondness for being boring.

Colby: I want to matter. Have you ever felt like that?
Damon: All the time.
Colby: Not just in family, but in life. Everybody thinks that I'm this spoiled blonde airhead, but I really,really want to do something with my life.
Damon: Trust me. You will.

I'd be more charitable and lean towards the former if I didn't have such a problem buying Damon as someone younger than 30. That's shallow and awful and not his fault, and by putting this out into the universe, I am pretty much outing myself as a younger version of Maxine from that line of Hallmark cards, but it's distracting me!


Ryan was exactly how he usually is--annoying, self-righteous and in the midst of a long pity party, but this time, he was that way while exercising. He spent almost the entire episode feeling sorry for himself while stretching and doing sit-ups and otherwise pandering quite blatantly to the throngs of Cameron Mathison fans in the audience.

While I am often swayed by a good-looking man, it didn't work this time, AMC, because I still wanted to hit him in the face for the duration of the episode.

Ryan: Tad, I've given her time. I have. I've been patient, and understanding, and I told her that I'd never stop loving her. I told her that whatever she wants, whatever she needs, I'll do that. But she swears the way I that I love her only hurts her.

"I've given her time"? How the hell much time could you have given her? She came back from the dead, like, three weeks ago! And you've been stalking her since! God!

But Tad is living in the same fantasy world, where Ryan is emperor and the ruler of all things who can do no wrong (...actually, that makes it sound kind of similar to the real Pine Valley, except in the fantasy world, Ryan's face is on the money) and all he did today was prop this asshole.

Tad: You're too good a man...


Tad: I'm sorry, if I pulled a Rip Van Winkle, I'd be angry, too. That doesn't make you the bad guy.

No, Tad, every other shitty thing that Ryan does on a daily basis is what makes him the bad guy. Ugggh, this show is making strides in the right direction on nearly every other front. Why the hell can't it realize that Ryan is never going to happen?!


Two things:

a) Can we keep this version of David? I like this one a lot more than the last one (and I remember you saying that if David was killed during the FAP days you would have actually DVR'd that). If they don't make Greenlee/David happen, they would be fools.

b) Yet another thing Ryan fails at: getting the message. Seriously? How many times does Greenlee have to tell him to back off and that being completely doing the opposite of what she wants will not win her back? That man is an asshat.

AMC is slowly pulling me back in...please don't screw it up now.

AMC is slowly pulling me back in...please don't screw it up now.
They will, but I'm gonna enjoy it while I can.

I could have written this post. It's really nice to see this version of David back. Damaged one day, noble the next and blackmailing on Fridays.

I'd given up soaps a while ago but I gave my heart to David and Greenlee seven years ago and never got it back. I never needed to get it back because I thought the writers left that idea way in the past so I wouldn't have to worry about it luring me back to soaps. Well, damn AMC for doing just that. So here I am, enjoying the fabulousness knowing that it'll end in my bitter tears.

The writing for Ryan wants to make me pull my hair out. Like yesterday his surprised "Where are you going?" when Greenlee chose to accompany her husband to the police station. Or him then complaining to "by the book" Jesse that he knew he had lost Greenlee by doing what he did but it didn't stop him from following her down to the cells downstairs. Do the writers even read what they write in previous scenes in the episode?

Like, what, am I supposed to be swept away by the great love of JR and Marissa?!

Well he did say that he only wanted to hold her hand. Too bad he will be screwing Annie by May. (No spoilers, just spec.)

The David and Greenlee magic hit me hard! David was so fierce in his love, he was scary. LB has brought him back to us in all his layers. VI is fabulous. Greenlee was all shades of subtle as she realized she was falling in love with David … but wisely realized until she reached his level of love she'd better keep her mouth shut. I've never seen RB do it better. So tell me, is it just possible AMC will explore Ryan with Madison and give us David and Greenlee? They're lightning in a bottle. And that doesn't come around too often!

I just fell even more in love with David and Greenlee yesterday. I've waited 7 years to see these two together and they are as magical as I thought they would be. AMC needs to pay attention an couple like this doesn't come along very often, a perfect blend of scheming together against PV and so incredibly sweet to each other.

I love David and Greenlee together. They have breathed new life into a nearly comatose show. I hope that AMC/ABC realizes what they have in this couple!

Well we had a wonderful romance- the best ever IMO- Zendall - only to have tiic blow it all to hell- many times over & ultimately stomp all over it. Glad you like Gravy because they do nothing for me.at.all. I left the show when Zen left & I'll be back when they're back next wk & then I'll be gone again- prob never to look
upon this train wreck again- unless Zen ever comes back permanently. What a shame.

Agreed about the David and Greenlee thing. They're magic. I can't believe I'm not weirded out that she used to be married to his brother, but it doesn't bother me at all. In fact, it makes me love them all the more.

The sad part is I made plans to quit watching this show (yes, I have to plan things like that) months ago when I heard about David Canary leaving the show. Arguably, I should have left when they killed Stuart, but like an ass I stuck with it. Now I'm hooked on David and Greenlee and don't want to stop watching anymore! Just my luck.

How I wish I could agree with you about David and Greenlee. While I adore Vincent Irizarry,and I'm happy they have finally changed him back to his 'old self' I loathe and detest Rebecca Budig and wished with all my heart Greenlee stayed dead. This actress has absolutely no feeling or heart. She acts like a twelve year old and VI deserves better. I was hoping for David and Erica.
The last great romance, and the best one in the last twenty years AMC had was Zach and Kendall and I don't see anyhting even close to the remarkable chemistry Thorsten and Alicia had in these two, primarily because of Budig.

I've also fallen hard for David/Greenlee, and I'm so delighted they're writing David in character again. These are the first pairings I've liked for these two since David/Anna and Greenlee/Leo. But will the writers see what gold they have here or keep insisting on boring, lousy Ryan/Greenlee?

Loved the commentary, thanks.

Totally in love with David and Greenlee! I sure hope the powers that be don't mess this up and saddle Greenlee with Ryan again.

On a tangent, when Jack called Erica "sister," (I think it was this episode) I cringed. He can NOT pull that jazz off! Is Jack's writer a wannabe beatnik? It's embarrassing.

The comments to this entry are closed.